Race to Nowhere: The Case Against Homework

Written by Tabby Biddle

Last Saturday in Los Angeles, I went to see Vicki Abeles’s film, Race to Nowhere. If you haven’t heard about this film already, check out the website right now. If you care anything about the future of our country, you are going to want to see this provocative film.

Race to Nowhere is about what it’s like for us right now living under the influence of the “No Child Left Behind” law, and if we stay on the path we are on, where we will most likely end up. In other words, it’s a documentary about the pressure epidemic running rampant in our school system. And who is affected? Kids, teachers, parents, families, school administrators, local communities, state and national governments. In other words, just about everybody.

Picture this: A middle school student, let’s call her Samantha, goes to school for seven hours, plays her sport after school for three hours, arrives home by about 7pm and eats a quick dinner as her parents drill her about her grades and her homework, then goes to her room to complete six hours of homework she has been given (1 hour for each subject because her teachers don’t want to look ‘lazy’), struggles to stay awake so she takes an Adderall that one of her friends who has been diagnosed with ADD gave to her so she can stay on top of her game and compete with the other students in her class. (Deep breath.) Okay, moving on.

In this process, Samantha discovers that skipping meals helps her stay awake at night and creates a kind of self-induced insomnia. Never mind the headaches she is getting every day due to the stress from the pressure to perform. Her parents are already talking about building her application for college admissions. Heck, the average weighted GPA to get into University of California Berkeley is 4.35. In other words, to get into the state university, students have to be more than perfect.

“We live in a society today where you have to be smart, but also have to be pretty, and also you have to do sports and you have to be involved in art, and you have to find something unique about yourself. And you have to know yourself, because if you don’t know yourself, before you do all that, you’re going to lose yourself,” says Kelly, a high school student interviewed in Race to Nowhere.

It’s interesting to note that businesses today are observing that recent college graduates are not coming to work armed with the skills of critical thinking and problem solving. Instead, business are noticing these graduates are more comfortable with and suited to memorize and take direction. Since “No Child Left Behind” (Bush signed into law in 2002) has brought about a culture of “teaching to the test,” the students rising through our education system are learning how to be great memorizers, but not critical thinkers. “I learn what I need to for the test, and then it’s gone,” reported one high school student.

How does this bode for the lives of young people and the future of our country?

too much homework taking a health toll on students

Not well of course. First off, health issues are a big concern. The number of young people suffering from headaches, chronic fatigue, anxiety, anorexia, obesity, depression and suicide is on the rise. In fact, not long after failing a math test, a thirteen-year-old young woman in Vicki’s community committed suicide. She was a straight-A student, extremely talented in music, loved nature and had a cheery disposition. It stunned everyone in Vicki’s community. Race to Nowhere is dedicated to her memory.

“Everyone expects us to be superheros.”  — a student in the film.

Many educators agree that our students today are pressured to perform, but they are not necessarily pressured to learn, especially to learn deeply and conceptually. “We are always looking at the next step,” said one educator. “They say that in elementary school we have them worrying about high school.”

The pressure to perform not only takes a toll on children’s physical health, but also their mental and emotional health. Studies have shown that over 80 percent of high school students are cheating because they feel it’s the only way to accomplish everything that has been put on their plate.

Teachers are under pressure too. If students don’t perform well (measured by test scores), it reflects badly on the teacher. The teacher is then at risk of losing money for her school, herself, and ultimately losing her job. For this reason, teachers have admitted to turning the other way when their students cheat. The formula: High scores = I can keep my job.

“We want to make sure that our kids aren’t always performing for adults … always filling in boxes for us … always looking good for us,” said Kenneth Ginsburg, MD, associate professor at The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and specialist in adolescent behavior, in an interview on Oprah radio. “We have to make sure they have some unscheduled downtime to really play … Play has huge development benefits for kids.”

According to Ginsburg and other medical and education experts, play helps children develop both socially and cognitively. In other words, free time on their own (as opposed to organized sports) allows children the opportunity to problem-solve, which in turn enhances their creativity. In an interview in the film, Vicki’s middle school daughter commented: “I can’t really remember the last time I had a chance to just go out in the back yard and just run around.”

The question remains how do we want to define success in our schools? A high GPA? Being class president? Captain of the soccer team? Maybe. But what about happiness? Is there a metric for happiness in our education system?

Right now we are caught on a treadmill of teaching to the test and pressuring kids to perform instead of learn. I think that pushing our kids to perform could actually be getting in the way of their success. If you ask me, instilling a lifelong love of learning is a really good path of happiness.

Look for my upcoming blog about things you can do to make a difference.

********************************************************************************

Tabby Biddle, M.S. Ed. is a writer specializing in women’s empowerment, personal growth and healthy living. She is a former classroom teacher and a current educator in lifelong learning. Her work has been featured by The Huffington Post, The Los Angeles Times, USA Today, and other national media. She lives in Santa Monica, CA with her husband.

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “Race to Nowhere: The Case Against Homework

  1. Pingback: NEW FEATURE! Goddess of the Week « The Goddess Diaries

    • I know Carole. It is disturbing. The good thing is that we can actually do something about it. One step at a time and not too difficult. I will be writing a follow-up post with some suggestions. Any one step counts and makes a difference.

      Wishing you a beautiful Friday,
      Tabby

  2. Go Girl!! Love love it:) I have not heard of Race to Nowhere but am going to send it to all my friends with kids! Thank you.

    • Thanks for your message Kim! Yes, yes, definitely tell your friends with kids about Race to Nowhere. They can request a screening in their city/town/school. I watched the film at the Skirball Education Center in LA and we got an hour afterward for Q & A with the director, Vicki. The dialogue was so lively. The audience was made up of parents, teachers and educators. It is super to get this dialogue going to initiate the necessary changes.

  3. How great that you request screenings – hopefully we can get enough interest to get Vicki to make an East coast tour!

  4. This pressure to perform is what I have been seeing with my grand daughters, and it is so stressful for them. In grade school, having to do multiple hours of homework every night…totally bad for children, and family life, and all about making them perform…

  5. That Gatto essay (The Seven Lesson Schoolteacher) had a huge impact on me, too. I was comfortable in all the conventional wisdom before I read that. Then I started following his links to source materials and realized that yeah, he’s right. The system is *designed* to create unthinking worker bees, and the design works really well.

    The issue that bothers me most is the amount of homework they’re giving to really young kids. Nine years old and two to three hours of homework per night. It’s ridiculous. And studies have shown *no benefit* to homework before high school level.

    My kids used to like school. The amount of homework — almost by itself — has made both of them not want to go any more.

  6. Love your blog! It is dead on to the work we are doing at our school for center-based and home-based education. We will definitely show support for your blog and “Race to Nowhere” as a truth to be told where the education of our children are concerned. Together, we’ll get through the red tape and make the change happen for our next generation of workers and leaders to start thinking through their responses instead of rhyming out boilerplate copy or rattling off a top 10 things to know list. To cultivate children and students who do have the confidence and self-esteem to be who they are vs. what they are told they should be. And while we’re at it, get those working now to “exit their own mentality” and start thinking differently as well! ” The Goddess Diaries” and “Goddess of the Week” – what a great way to place focus on demanding a positive, results-oriented culture that works to impact the real needs and issues that face us today. Thanks Tabby!

  7. Pingback: The Biggest Killer of Loving to Learn: School « The Goddess Diaries

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s